Local residents are talking about transforming Alta Vista into a “15-minute neighbourhood,” but efforts to make the community more walkable have been overshadowed by concerns about City of Ottawa plans for intensification that come with the proposed changes.
“When people became aware of this issue, it was very focused on the intensification, and not so much the benefits,” said Marty Carr, president of the Alta Vista Community Association. “We haven’t really been able to focus too much on the 15-minute neighbourhood plan.”
A ’15-minute neighbourhood’ envisions a community that is walkable and “complete” — in other words, it is a cyclist and pedestrian-friendly neighbourhood that has shops, services, parks, facilities for recreation, learning and worship, all within a safe and enjoyable 15-minute walking distance, according to Ecology Ottawa.
“We’re in an environmental crisis. The point is to actually shift our behaviours to make an impact,” said Rosaline Hill, an architect and representative from Walkable Ottawa who has been part of the initiative to make Alta Vista walker-friendly.
Plans to transform Alta Vista and other neighbourhoods in Ottawa into 15-minute neighbourhoods were outlined in the Draft New Official Plan released by the City of Ottawa in November. The 264-page document was designed as a policy framework to guide the growth and development of the city until 2046.
One of the other key priorities outlined in the plan is residential intensification — or “regeneration” as it is called in the plan – in select neighbourhoods.
Intensification means increasing residential density by means of more multi-unit dwellings and greater public transit to reduce urban sprawl and its environmental impacts.
Alta Vista has been slated for relatively rapid intensification, including more multi-unit developments in a neighbourhood of mostly single detached homes.
But that plan has been met with intense concern and feedback from many Ottawa residents, especially those living in Alta Vista.
Plan lacks clarity
A lack of clarity in the city’s plan has been a big driver of community concern, according to Hill and Carr.
“The information in the draft seems really very clumsy when it comes to neighbourhoods like theirs. So, there’s a lot of concern, and rightly so,” said Hill.
“They want to understand the impact to their property, the impact to their streets, and the impact to their neighbourhoods — and there wasn’t clarity around that,” said Carr. “You’re just given these minimum density targets and told there’s going to be a 15-minute neighbourhood concept brought in, but people don’t know what that means and that was worrisome for people.”
A meeting with city staff was held in early March to try to clarify issues being raised by the Alta Vista community. More than 500 people took part in the virtual meeting.
The most important message delivered by the city during the meeting was that intensification did not include plans to fill every street in the community with apartment buildings, according to Carr.
“People were very concerned about developers coming, buying up every available property and then developing them into multi-unit buildings. The character of the community would be destroyed,” said Carr.
These concerns have affected the 15-minute neighbourhood workshops held over the last month by Ecology Ottawa and Walkable Ottawa, which were designed to consult with local residents about creating a more pedestrian-friendly community.
“What we’ve been seeing with the workshops is that communities are really enraged by this description of a small house being knocked down for a bigger house,” said Cheryl Randall, the Climate Change Campaign Organizer at Ecology Ottawa.
As a community that is dominated by cars and almost completely lacks sidewalks and bike paths, Alta Vista needs to be transformed into a 15-minute neighbourhood before it can be intensified, according to Hill.
“It’s targeted for fairly high densities. It’s targeted for limited vehicular parking – so far walkable-type development projects – but in a neighbourhood that is so profoundly not practically walkable,” said Hill. “There’s lots that really needs to be done to make the plan for Alta Vista realistic.”
Carr said infrastructure improvements such as a community centre, bus services, and more local businesses need to be made before Alta Vista can become a 15-minute neighbourhood.
“The 15-minute concept – I think it’s going to take a lot of selling to people. But I think there’s quite a few people who are really interested in it and enthusiastic about it. But they really feel that we need the improvements to the neighbourhood made first,” said Carr.
Regardless, Randall says the workshops are vital in moulding the Official Plan as it goes through redrafting.
“If the city took those concerns or suggestions on board, then neighbourhoods could really become the vibrant, healthy entities that we need them to become,” said Randall.
It seems as if the Official Plan is something that can only be fully understood when it starts to play out. Ask the citizens of Westboro how much they are enjoying it so far. And no one seems to consider that folks may not appreciate such planned density if ever we are embroiled in another pandemic.
On the Official Plan debate, an issue the media has not yet noted in any detail, but which has lots of interest and would get a lot off attention, is the one trend not expected to change due to Covid: the growing population of seniors (a significant Alta Vista demographic). After reading the OP in detail, I and others working on this file noted only passing references to seniors/aging population and nothing specific related to their housing wishes and needs for the future. Contact the Council on Aging of Ottawa and ask for their comments on the OP, which highlight their areas of concern about what is missing (and this is after years of being part of the OP discussion with the City) — or contact me by e-mail and I can send you a copy of the. And note the seniors demographic is expected to grow significantly (from 16% in 2018 to 22% by 2046) and their issues include downsizing options for healthy aging (and wishes to stay in neighborhoods they know), as well as senior’s residences and long-term care when needed.
And by way of background, I am a long-time journalist (as well as communications consultant and EA/ECE when Covid doesn’t interfere with my job world).